
I Am Not a Serial Killer (2016)
Film · Horror, Mystery, Crime
Stream it, iffor viewers who want a clever, offbeat supernatural thriller rather than a straightforward one.
A genre-bending thriller that blends small-town grit with a supernatural twist and dark, dry humor. It is an unusual, atmospheric film for viewers who want a clever spin on the traditional serial killer narrative.
The premise
In a small Midwestern town, a troubled teen with homicidal tendencies must hunt down and destroy a supernatural killer while keeping his own inner demons at bay.
Trailer
What I Am Not a Serial Killer is like, and who it is for
What it is like to watch
A small Minnesota town sits under snow and suspicion. A teenager who is sure he is a psychopath — and who has the instincts to prove it — discovers that the local murders are not the work of a man. What follows is a hunt that corners him with his own darkness. The tone is tense but flecked with dry, deadpan humour, and the atmosphere is lived-in, wintry and quietly gothic.
Who made it, and how it landed
Billy O'Brien directs with a steady, character-first hand, and Max Records carries the film as the sharp, unsettling protagonist; Christopher Lloyd brings a melancholic presence. Critics were largely enthusiastic, with a 93% Rotten Tomatoes score praising its blend of gore and wit, although Metacritic's 54 suggests a more divided response, and RogerEbert.com was frankly hostile. Expect a slow-burn tone rather than an all-out horror.
Who it is for, and who should skip it
This is for viewers who like their horror with a literary bent and a supernatural twist — fans of dark coming-of-age stories will find plenty. Those wanting relentless scares or fast pacing should look elsewhere, and the grimness and occasional gore may put off the faint-hearted. It is a film that rewards patience and an appetite for moral ambiguity.
The right evening for it
It suits a wintry night when you are in the mood for something atmospheric and quietly unsettling rather than loud — a bleak but oddly warm watch that lingers.
Written by our AI from the facts on this page. It has opinions; it has not watched it.
Clip
Clip · Clip: False Alarm
How I Am Not a Serial Killer leaves you
One line on the mood it ends on, with no plot. Some people count that as a spoiler, so it stays hidden until you ask.
Unsettled and thoughtful, with a wry, cold smile — the kind of film that lingers like frost on a window.
How I Am Not a Serial Killer ends
Spoilers. The whole ending, in a few lines. Nothing shows until you ask and then confirm.
The film ends with John ambushing Crowley in the funeral home, knocking him out and, with his mother April, attaching him to the embalming device. When Crowley wakes, a large black oily monster slides out of his body. Realising he can no longer be with Kay, Crowley asks John to watch over her and then kills himself; his body and the monster melt into black oil. The police later find Grant's body, and Crowley is reported missing. John comforts Kay, who tells him how she and Crowley fell in love, and this makes John realise he can find happiness too. The film closes on John and April embalming Grant's body together.
Summarised by our AI from the plot section of the Wikipedia article, available under CC BY-SA 4.0. This summary is shared under the same licence.
Stills
Images from TMDB.
If you like this, try

The Pale Blue Eye (2022)
film · Tense · IMDb 6.6 · In English, French and Latin
A cold, methodical period mystery that thrives on a bleak atmosphere and a sense of growing unease. The deliberate pace and grim subject matter make it a rewarding watch for those who prefer intellectual dread and gothic aesthetics over high-speed action.
a wintry small-town mystery with a supernatural undercurrent

1922 (2017)
film · Tense · IMDb 6.2
A grim, slow-burn adaptation of Stephen King that focuses on the psychological rot and guilt following a brutal crime. It is a punishing, bleak experience that trades jump scares for a sense of inevitable, creeping dread.
a bleak, character-led crime drama in a snowy setting

Absentia (2011)
film · Tense · IMDb 5.8
A low-budget, high-dread mystery that relies on psychological unease rather than jump scares. It is a somber and atmospheric slow-burn for viewers who prefer lingering uncertainty over explicit gore.
a low-key supernatural mystery with a suffocating atmosphere
Suggested by our AI for what they share with this one. Linked titles have a page here; the rest are worth a search on the browse page.
I Am Not a Serial Killer soundtrack
Music by Adrian Johnston
Questions people ask
- Is I Am Not a Serial Killer a tense film?
- Yes. On Watchlist Boosted it is tagged Tense, with a funny streak. A genre-bending thriller that blends small-town grit with a supernatural twist and dark, dry humor. It is an unusual, atmospheric film for viewers who want a clever spin on the traditional serial killer narrative.
- How long is I Am Not a Serial Killer?
- I Am Not a Serial Killer runs 104 min and was released in 2016.
- Where can I watch I Am Not a Serial Killer in Australia?
- In Australia, I Am Not a Serial Killer is included with Prime Video (all plans).
- Who composed the music for I Am Not a Serial Killer?
- The music for I Am Not a Serial Killer is by Adrian Johnston.
- Is I Am Not a Serial Killer worth watching?
- It depends: for viewers who want a clever, offbeat supernatural thriller rather than a straightforward one. IMDb users rate it 6.2 out of 10 from 17,153 votes, Rotten Tomatoes gives it 93%, Metacritic 54 and TMDB users 6.3.
More tense titles
Same mood, saved by people here. See all tense titles.

Brick (2025)
film · Tense · IMDb 5.5 · In German and English
A high-intensity chamber piece that turns an impossible mystery into a desperate fight for survival. It is claustrophobic and dark, focused on the shifting alliances and rising panic of people pushed to their absolute limits.

Wayward (2025)
series · Tense · IMDb 5.9
A suspenseful mystery set in the claustrophobic environment of a school for troubled teens, focusing on power dynamics and manipulation. It starts with a strong hook and maintains a steady sense of unease as the dark secrets of the founder emerge.

Inside Man (2006)
film · Tense · IMDb 7.6 · In English and Albanian
A sharp and sophisticated heist thriller that trades mindless explosions for clever dialogue and an intricate, layered plot. It is highly polished and entertaining, offering a satisfying intellectual puzzle.

Lanterns (2026)
series · Tense · IMDb 7.8
A dark and grounded mystery that brings a gritty, noir-like intensity to a science fiction setting. It is a slow-burn investigation designed for viewers who prefer a high-stakes crime drama over traditional superhero spectacle.

Curry & Cyanide: The Jolly Joseph Case (2023)
documentary · Tense · IMDb 6.7 · In Malayalam and English
A chilling and straightforward account of a series of domestic poisonings that feels both intimate and horrifying. It is a grim, slow-burn investigation that relies on the inherent shock value of its central figure to keep the viewer engaged.

Obsession (2026)
film · Tense · IMDb 7.8
A dark supernatural thriller where the "be careful what you wish for" trope takes a sinister turn. Expect a slow-building sense of dread that culminates in a punishing price for the protagonist's desires.


